Bicycle Thief Menu Prices In Canada
I found Bicycle Thief a while ago, and now it’s one of my go-to places for Italian food. I’ve been there several times, and I think it’s worth talking about.
They have fresh seafood and homemade pasta on the menu. The prices are mixed—some dishes are cheap, others are more expensive. There’s something for everyone, really.
I’m sharing what I’ve actually ordered and eaten there. I’ll tell you what was good, what wasn’t, and if the prices make sense. Let’s get into it.
A Closer Look at Bicycle Thief’s Complete Menu and Prices
I’ve put together all the menu details and prices I found during my visits to Bicycle Thief. Below, you’ll see everything organized by category, so you can plan what to order and how much to budget before you go.
Lunch
| Menu Item | Price |
| Antipasti Board | CAN $24.00 |
| Home-Grown Mussels | CAN $14.00 |
| Two-Minute Flash-Fried Calamari | CAN $14.00 |
| Jumbo Shrimp | CAN $16.00 |
| Yellowfin Tuna Tartare | CAN $16.00 |
| Fresh Burrata | CAN $16.00 |
| Seared Local Scallops | CAN $17.00 |
| Lobster & Corn Chowder | CAN $19.00 |
| Caramelized Onion Tart | CAN $14.00 |
| Radicchio & Cabbage | CAN $14.00 |
| Insalata Panzanella Invernale | CAN $14.00 |
| Insalata Verde | CAN $14.00 |
| Insalata Di Polpo | CAN $18.00 |
| Downeast Fresh Lobster Roll | CAN $26.00 |
| Seared Steak Sandwich | CAN $26.00 |
| Housemade Fish Cakes | CAN $22.00 |
| BT Chopped Tenderloin Burger | CAN $24.00 |
| Slow Roasted Pork Ribs (Lunch) | CAN $20.00 |
| Pistachio Honey-Crusted Atlantic Salmon (Lunch) | CAN $36.00 |
| Linguine Fra Diavolo | CAN $24.00 |
| Cannelloni | CAN $26.00 |
| Red Ravioli | CAN $24.00 |
| Spaghettini Ai Frutti Di Mare | CAN $28.00 |
| Tagliatelle Bolognese | CAN $24.00 |
| Strozzapreti Di Salsiccia | CAN $24.00 |
| Agnolotti All’Aragosta | CAN $32.00 |
| Gnocchi Di Patate | CAN $24.00 |
| Local Oysters (Per Piece) | CAN $3.50 |
Dinner
| Menu Item | Price |
| The Freshest Local Oysters (Per Piece) | CAN $3.50 |
| Antipasti Board | CAN $24.00 |
| Two-Minute Flash-Fried Calamari | CAN $14.00 |
| BT’s Beef Tenderloin Tartare | CAN $22.00 |
| Home-Grown Mussels | CAN $14.00 |
| Slow Roasted Pork Ribs | CAN $14.00 |
| Jumbo Shrimp | CAN $16.00 |
| Yellowfin Tuna Tartare | CAN $16.00 |
| Fresh Burrata | CAN $16.00 |
| Seared Local Scallops | CAN $17.00 |
| Lobster & Corn Chowder | CAN $19.00 |
| Caramelized Onion Tart | CAN $14.00 |
| Radicchio & Cabbage | CAN $14.00 |
| Insalata Panzanella Invernale | CAN $14.00 |
| Insalata Verde | CAN $14.00 |
| Insalata Di Polpo | CAN $18.00 |
| Linguine Fra Diavolo | CAN $24.00 |
| Tagliatelle Bolognese | CAN $24.00 |
| Agnolotti All’Aragosta | CAN $32.00 |
| Strozzapreti Di Salsiccia | CAN $24.00 |
| Spaghettini Ai Frutti Di Mare | CAN $28.00 |
| Cannelloni | CAN $26.00 |
| Red Ravioli | CAN $24.00 |
| Gnocchi Di Patate | CAN $24.00 |
| Risotto All’Anatra | CAN $36.00 |
| Cioppino | CAN $46.00 |
| Pistachio Honey-Crusted Atlantic Salmon | CAN $36.00 |
| Seared Atlantic Halibut | CAN $38.00 |
| Old-School Lobster Thermidor | CAN $50.00 |
| Tagliata | CAN $52.00 |
| Pollo Al Marsala | CAN $34.00 |
| Roasted Beef Short Rib ‘Al Barolo’ | CAN $44.00 |
| BT Chopped Tenderloin Burger | CAN $24.00 |
| Rack Of Lamb | CAN $54.00 |
| Butterscotch Caramel Cake | CAN $14.00 |
| Torta Al Limone | CAN $14.00 |
| Crème Brûlée | CAN $14.00 |
| Crostata Di Pere | CAN $14.00 |
| Torta Al Cioccolato | CAN $14.00 |
| Pistachio Basque Cheesecake | CAN $14.00 |
| Peanut Butter & Chocolate Ripple Sundae | CAN $14.00 |
DESSERT / FINALE
| Menu Item | Price |
| Our Lovely Layered Butterscotch Caramel Cake, Crushed Toasted Pecans | CAN $14.00 |
| Torta Al Limone, Baked Lemon Tart, Torched Italian Meringue, Shortbread Crust, Cassis Coulis | CAN $14.00 |
| Crème Brûlée, Madagascar Vanilla | CAN $14.00 |
| Crostata Di Pere, Almond Frangipane, Prosecco Poached Pears, Mexican Chocolate Gelato | CAN $14.00 |
| Torta Al Cioccolato, 12 Layers Of Chocolate Cake, Chocolate Cream & Coffee Liqueur Ganache | CAN $14.00 |
| Pistachio Basque Cheesecake, Toasted Pistachio Butter, Clementine Marmellata | CAN $14.00 |
| Peanut Butter & Chocolate Ripple Sundae, Hot Fudge Sauce, Peanut Brittle, Whipped Cream | CAN $14.00 |
Most Popular Menu Items at Bicycle Thief Canada
After visiting multiple times, I noticed certain dishes appeared on almost every table. These are the most popular items I saw people ordering again and again. Here’s what seems to be the crowd favorites based on my observations.
Tagliatelle Bolognese
This classic pasta dish at CAN $24 is what I’d recommend if you’re visiting for the first time. The slow-cooked meat sauce is rich and hearty, clinging perfectly to the fresh tagliatelle. It’s comfort food done right, and honestly, it’s the dish I keep coming back for.
Pistachio Honey-Crusted Atlantic Salmon
At CAN $36, this salmon is absolutely worth the splurge. The pistachio-honey crust adds an incredible sweetness and crunch that complements the fresh Atlantic salmon beautifully. If you love seafood but want something a bit different from standard preparations, this is your dish.
Two-Minute Flash-Fried Calamari
In my opinion, this CAN $14 appetizer is the perfect way to start your meal. The calamari is crispy, tender, and never rubbery – which is rare to find. It’s a crowd-pleaser that even people who think they don’t like calamari end up enjoying.
Agnolotti All’Aragosta
This lobster-filled pasta costs CAN $32, making it the priciest pasta option, but the generous lobster filling and delicate sauce make it special-occasion worthy. I’d suggest ordering this when you’re celebrating something or just want to treat yourself to something truly indulgent.
Fresh Burrata
For CAN $16, you get creamy, silky burrata cheese that practically melts in your mouth. This appetizer is popular with both cheese lovers and people looking for a lighter start. It’s simple, elegant, and pairs beautifully with their fresh bread.
BT Chopped Tenderloin Burger
At CAN $24, this isn’t your average burger. The high-quality beef tenderloin makes all the difference, and you can really taste it. Perfect for lunch or when you want something satisfying without going too heavy on Italian fare.
Spaghettini Ai Frutti Di Mare
This seafood pasta at CAN $28 comes loaded with mussels, shrimp, and calamari in a beautiful sauce. If you’re a seafood lover like me, this dish delivers on both quantity and quality. The portions are generous, and the seafood tastes incredibly fresh.
Lobster & Corn Chowder
I would recommend this CAN $19 soup on any chilly day. It’s rich, creamy, and packed with real lobster chunks – not just token pieces. This is comfort in a bowl, and it’s become one of my automatic orders during colder months.
Alternative to Bicycle Thief Canada
If Bicycle Thief doesn’t fit your budget or you’re looking for something different, I’ve got you covered. Here are some great alternatives that offer similar quality food or atmosphere, based on places I’ve also tried and enjoyed.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the prices for the kids’ menu at Bicycle Thief Canada?
If children order from the regular menu, expect pricing aligned with those items — often CAN $14 to $24 for lighter entrées. It’s common for restaurants of this style to accommodate kids by modifying portions rather than having a dedicated menu.
How much does the gluten‑free menu at Bicycle Thief Canada cost?
Bicycle Thief Canada doesn’t list a distinct gluten‑free price tier, but many dishes can be prepared gluten‑free upon request. Prices generally follow the regular menu items (for example, salads and seafood prepared gluten‑free usually remain within the normal price range of CAN $14–$36+).
What are the prices of vegetarian menu options at Bicycle Thief Canada?
Vegetarian‑friendly choices like salads and pasta dishes at Bicycle Thief Canada are priced similarly to other entrées — typically from CAN $14 to $28, depending on the dish. For instance, simple salads are usually CAN $14, while richer pastas can be around CAN $24–$28.
What are the seasonal or limited‑time menu prices at Bicycle Thief Canada?
Seasonal or limited‑time items at Bicycle Thief Canada — such as special seafood or holiday dishes — are priced within the usual restaurant range depending on ingredients. Since these menus change often, prices are typically similar to regular dinner entrées, generally from CAN $24 to $50+ for premium seasonal fare. Â
Are there any happy hour menu prices at Bicycle Thief Canada?
Bicycle Thief Canada’s standard published menus do not list specific happy hour pricing. If the restaurant runs specials or happy hour deals, those are typically announced locally or in‑house rather than listed on regular menus.
What are the most expensive menu items at Bicycle Thief Canada?
Bicycle Thief Canada’s priciest dishes tend to be its premium entrées and specialty mains, often featuring high‑quality proteins and luxurious ingredients. Here are some of the most expensive options on the dinner menu:
- Rack Of Lamb – CAN $54.00
- Tagliata – CAN $52.00
- Old‑School Lobster Thermidor – CAN $50.00
- Cioppino – CAN $46.00
What are the cheapest menu items at Bicycle Thief Canada?
At Bicycle Thief Canada, the most affordable items are typically small appetizers or simple bites. These are great if you want to start light or enjoy a budget‑friendly option from the menu:
- Local Oysters (per piece) – CAN $3.50
- Two‑Minute Flash‑Fried Calamari – CAN $14.00
- Caramelized Onion Tart – CAN $14.00
- Radicchio & Cabbage – CAN $14.00
Final Thoughts
After all my visits to Bicycle Thief, I can confidently say it’s worth experiencing at least once. The fresh ingredients, handmade pasta, and attention to detail justify the prices. Whether you’re going for a casual lunch or celebrating something special, you’ll find dishes that impress.
Have you been to Bicycle Thief? I’d love to hear about your experience! Share your thoughts in the comment box below and let other Canadians know which dishes you tried and loved. Your feedback helps everyone make better dining decisions!
Justin George
Hi, I’m Justin George, the creator of Menu Prices in Canada. My love for food and curiosity about local dining experiences inspired me to explore Canada’s vibrant restaurant menus from famous fast-food chains to hidden neighborhood spots.
I started this website to make it easier for food-loving Canadians like me to find the most comprehensive, accurate, and up-to-date menus and prices from top restaurants and fast-food chains across Canada, all listed in Canadian dollars. Whether you’re craving a quick bite or planning a special meal, I’m here to help you make informed choices without breaking the bank.
